
Copyright from partner Endemol, Pinoy Dream Academy is Kapamilya's version of reality search for the next singing sensation. The format is similar to
Big Brother, where a set number of finalists (billed as "scholars" throughout the series) would live inside the Academy for four months and will be trained by guest teachers to be multimedia performers. Activities in the Academy are being monitored
24/7 by the headmaster. It uses the tagline
Ang drama sa likod ng pangarap (The drama behind the dream). The program is aired through
ABS-CBN.
ABS-CBN affiliate Studio 23 airs a companion program under the same title. It is a separate show from the flagship station that will feature scenes that were not shown on the main program and has different hosts.
The Gala Night was performed every saturday via ABS-CBN and also the announcement of expelled scholar. The probationary announcement, on the other hand, is done every sunday. There is a bonus for PDA season 2 with the performance of Little Big Dreamers every sunday. The Little Big Dreamers is for the children level, and I love to see these little kids do their own rendition of the songs. This portion was not staged during the season 1, which is an advantage because viewers get to witness the variety of the show.
The contestants' life inside the Academy is chronicled on the nightly episodes from Monday to Friday. This includes the classes the students have to take and their domestic time outside of these classes.
The episodes shown on Saturday (sometimes known as the Gala Nights) showcase the talents of the contestants, and exemplifies the progress of each of them in regards to their education in the Academy. In these nights, they mostly show singing performances, although in some cases, there are also dance numbers prepared by the scholars themselves.
Every Sunday, the contestants are assessed by the jury from the performance night.[1] The probationary students and the Star Scholar was determined in this episode. The probationary students are the four scholars who obtained the lowest scores in the performance night while Star Scholar is the one who gets the highest. In the first season, if a scholar obtains the highest score from the judges for two consecutive weeks, that scholar will only get the title of Star Scholar in the first week; the title then has to be passed to the second highest pointing scholar in the second week. However, this ruling was changed in the second season, allowing a scholar to be the Star Scholar of the week for several consecutive weeks.
PROS:
Being a scholar is prestigious.ABS-CBN had hired the best people in the music scene to mentor the scholars in different aspects. These key personnel are highly reckoned with on the music scene and mind you, their fees are also "high" if you want to hire them personally - An average Filipino cannot afford to pay them all in one package for a span of 4 months!
Headmaster: Jim Paredes(season1)/Ryan Cayabyab(season2)
Performing Arts: Jose Javier Reyes
Voice teachers: Moy Ortiz/Kitchie Molina
Jurors: Gerard Salonga, Jimmy Antiporda, Loiue Ocampo, and other credible music gurus
Other trainings include diction, dance, fitness, songwriting, etc., which implies the "scholarship" to stay in the "academy" to be trained and equipped as singers and performers.
Definitely, nobody will not turn down the above mentioned trainings to be gained from highly respected mentors!
Viewers who wants to learn would also prefer PDA since clips of the trainings being done to the scholars are showed on TV. These insights can be inculcated in the mind of the viewer and they will also benefit from it.
Of course, "gossips" and "personal issues" are mostly shown on primetime, but its part of the show. Somebody might say its a talent search, so why should these issues need to be shown? While i agree that these portions are mostly shown because they want to attract more viewers through them, the reality is, more issues and gossips will be dealt with by the aspiring singers in the outside world. Besides, every show is doing it and Filipino culture "want" them.
On the voting portion, Endemol created a very good rubrics of the show. By being
objective, the scholars are assessed by the jury from the performance night.
[1] The probationary students and the Star Scholar was determined in this episode. The probationary students are the four scholars who obtained the lowest scores in the performance night while Star Scholar is the one who gets the highest. In the first season, if a scholar obtains the highest score from the judges for two consecutive weeks, that scholar will only get the title of Star Scholar in the first week; the title then has to be passed to the second highest pointing scholar in the second week. However, this ruling was changed in the second season, allowing a scholar to be the Star Scholar of the week for several consecutive weeks.
I believe that this rule is best for Filipinos since we are also used to vote and like the artists based on their outside appearance despite the unoutstanding performance of an artist. With the objectivity of the matter, the scholar which to be expelled are chosen by the jurors through the grading system.
The scholars on probation will now have to be saved by the viewers which determines their "charisma" and "saleability" in the near future.
With these ruling, the best singer will definitely remain and cannot be expelled unless she/he performed terribly.
CONS:A scholar will be "confined" in the academy for more than 4 months. However, an open-minded scholar need to set his/her mind on this, having them known this kind of rule before they enter the academy. Man, you need to sacrifice for your dreams!
I'm totally pissed off and frustrated (same as Direk Joey) with the season 2 scholars (except for Chivas whose voluntary exit is due to health problems) who exited because of missing their families.
I have to reiterate, man, you need to sacrifice for your dreams! That excuse is so not acceptable!
I dont see any disadvantage for this show. Win-win situation for all parties: scholars, viewers, of course, ABS-CBN need to have sponsors to finance the show...
MY BET:Season 1 finalists are way better than the season 2 scholars. In fact, I was one of those who voted seriously for Yeng everytime she's in probation. I was not disappointed as she earned the Star Dreamer because of her vast talent and distinctive voice. Other season 1 scholars, though not won, are still way better than the season 2 finalists. The likes of Panky, Yvan, and Jay-R, to name them, are good singers.
I'm looking for someone who has that distinctive voice, one who can carry a song and call it her own. One who is original and can sing any song with her "label". Unluckily, i am not seeing this potential to any of the season 2 scholars. Liezl sings well and carries her notes flawlessly but i pardon me if i say I am not seeing her to shine like Yeng and Jay-R. RJ, on the other hand, even if he is not very good in handling his notes, had an RJ voice, plus his songwriting talent gave him an album. Again, I can't hear a distinction in Liezl - her voice is "general". I like Bugoy with his R&B style though, but he can't beat the likes of JayR (SOP) in this genre. Plus, he kinda fail in the looks department, we must admit it.
Other scholars are OK but not exceptional. I will not be giving a single vote to any PDA scholar this season. I will just be an spectator, but will not join in the voting part compared to my addiction the last season.
Finally, I would chose Pinoy Dream Academy than Pinoy Idol mainly because PDA had a better ruling. I resist to be bias in this aspect and definitely basing my decision with the PROS & CONS of these two competing shows. The result of the voting and expulsion process gives us a clear view of how Filipinos chose their talent. The better singers in Pinoy Idol are being eliminated while scholars who are performing well can't be expelled in PDA because of the grading and probation system.Promised prices for the "chosen" are almost the same - both are eye-popping!
Who earns more? I don't have any figure comparing the number of votes being received by the two shows but since PDA allows only two scholars to vote for in a week compared to PI's all idol hopefuls, i think, PI earns more with the text votes.
Wishful thinking: Kitchie Nadal to enter PDA house for one day to share herself to the aspiring singers. It could also be in Pinoy Idol since judge Jolina is her friend... hehe